Funds · · 8 min read

Inside an ETF: How Exchange-Traded Funds Actually Work

Exchange-traded funds combine features of mutual funds and individual shares. Understanding their plumbing — creation, redemption and pricing — explains much of how they behave.

What is an ETF?

An exchange-traded fund (ETF) is an investment fund whose units trade on a stock exchange throughout the day, like shares. The fund holds a portfolio of assets — such as stocks, bonds or commodities — and each unit represents a proportional interest in that portfolio.

Canada has a notable place in ETF history: one of the world's first index-tracking ETFs was launched on the Toronto Stock Exchange in 1990.

Index tracking

Many ETFs aim to track an index — a rules-based list of securities, such as a broad selection of large companies. The fund holds the index components (or a representative sample) so that its performance follows the index before costs.

The difference between the fund's return and the index's return is called tracking difference. Fees, trading costs and cash holdings all contribute to it.

Creation and redemption

The mechanism that sets ETFs apart involves large financial institutions known as authorized participants (in Canada, often called designated brokers or dealers):

  1. Creation: the participant delivers a basket of the underlying securities (or cash) to the fund and receives a block of new ETF units.
  2. Redemption: the participant returns a block of ETF units and receives the underlying basket back.

This process lets the number of units expand or shrink with demand.

Market price vs. net asset value

Each ETF has a net asset value (NAV): the value of its holdings minus liabilities, divided by units outstanding. Its market price is set by trading on the exchange and can drift slightly above (a premium) or below (a discount) the NAV.

The creation and redemption process creates an incentive that tends to pull the market price back toward NAV: when a gap appears, participants can create or redeem units and trade the difference.

ETFs vs. mutual funds

  • Trading: ETF units trade during market hours; mutual fund units are typically bought or redeemed once a day at the closing NAV.
  • Costs: both charge a management expense ratio (MER); ETF buyers may also face trading commissions and bid-ask spreads.
  • Structure: both pool investors' money and are subject to securities regulation and disclosure requirements.

This comparison is educational and general. It is not a recommendation of any type of fund.

This article is educational material. It is not personalized financial, tax or investment advice.